|
Three
River Technologies -- Simulation of the Vibrational Response of a Rifle
Barrel During Firing
By Kevin
N. Schwinkendorf and Steven P. Roblyer
Abstract
A device that controls
rifle barrel vibration and improves bullet accuracy was evaluated and
designed by computer simulation. A computer program was written by the
authors to solve the transient form of the elastic beam vibration equation
for any given driving function. Output consists of binary files containing
transverse velocity and displacement profiles. These files are readable
by FFT post-processing codes and by PV-WAVE®
procedure files, which display animations of the system. FFT post-processing
was performed to benchmark and verify the simulator with analytical solutions
of mode shapes and frequencies. The simulator then was used to optimize
a design for a set of rifle barrel modifications that alter the vibrational
response to minimize the angular dispersion, or slope, at the muzzle.
Bullets will thus exit the barrel always pointing in the same direction
(parallel to the barrel baseline axis). This minimizes the sensitivity
of precision (measured by group size) to bullet exit time and vibration
initiators. Rifle accuracy is thereby improved for a wide range of loads
for a given rifle.
Introduction
Barrel vibration
is one of the factors affecting the accuracy of rifles. Variations in
loads (propellant charge weights and bullet masses) cause different times-of-flight
from primer ignition to the point in time when the bullet leaves the muzzle.
These variations cause the bullet to impact in different locations around
the point of aim. The size of the bullet dispersion is called group size.
Handloaders have typically reduced bullet group size by "tuning" (or adjusting)
the powder load to the barrel so that minimum bullet group size results.
The goal is to get the bullet to exit the barrel at a point of maximum
barrel deflection, as this represents a point of minimum time-rate-of-change
in barrel slope at the muzzle. This minimizes the sensitivity of bullet
dispersion to statistical muzzle velocity variation. A new approach was
investigated that improves firearm precision by significantly reducing
the magnitude of the angular dispersion of the muzzle over a window of
relevant bullet exit times.
Proposed modifications
to the barrel control the shape of the vibrational response so that the
barrel slope at the muzzle is minimized. The first modification (addition
of a mass to the barrel between the breech and the muzzle) isolates the
muzzle from much of the vibrational energy initiated between it and the
chamber through inertial damping (reflection). The second modification
(addition of a flexible cylindrical extension and mass attached to the
muzzle) acts as a cantilever harmonic oscillator, providing a periodic
bending moment to alter the shape of the vibrational response associated
with the transmitted vibrational energy. This flexible extension is designed
so that the barrel slope is minimized at the point where the bullet leaves
physical contact with the barrel, and its flight is determined. The barrel
extension has an inner diameter larger than the bore diameter and gas
release slots to reduce the effect of gas upsetting the bullet after it
has left the muzzle. The design goal is to optimize the positions of the
two masses, the radial dimensions and length of the extension, and the
configuration of lengthwise slots in the extension to minimize the slope
of the muzzle over a window of bullet exit times. This is accomplished
when the barrel and flexible extension forms a resonating segment between
the masses so that any vibrational energy transmitted past the first mass
forms a symmetrical standing wave. The location of zero barrel slope (half
the standing wavelength) is designed to coincide with where the bullet
enters the extension and leaves physical contact with the barrel. The
bullet exits the barrel parallel to the baseline axis for an extended
window of bullet exit times, resulting in significantly less sensitivity
to variations in exit times.
Rifle barrel vibration
is initiated by mechanical interaction between the barrel and the bullet
accelerating down the bore, as well as by the severe pressure transient
arising from the burning propellant. Barrel vibrations are considered,
for this application, to be a superposition of transverse vibrational
modes initiated at a continuum of points along the barrel. The short-term
vibrational response includes a particular solution arising from the specific
characteristics of the driving function (the operating deflection shape),
but this response will rapidly transition into the natural modes for the
barrel itself. Although this transition takes longer to occur than the
time required for the bullet to exit the barrel, comparisons with natural
mode shapes and frequencies allow independent verification of the simulator.
|